Choice in 2010: “Simplicity” or “Complexity”
|
Emissions standards for diesel-powered
commercial trucks will change again in 2010.
But your purchase criteria will remain the
same then as today. You will want trucks that
perform with every turn of the key. So, you’ll
continue to look for performance, reliability,
durability, low cost of ownership, and ease of
maintenance. And, once again, you need not
look any further than International® trucks
powered by MaxxForce™ engines.
For 2010, Navistar will meet new EPA
standards with advanced engine and vehicle
systems featuring EGR. Some truck makers
will offer emissions systems that incorporate
SCR (Selective Catalytic Reduction) an
after-treatment approach versus a proven
in-cylinder solution. EGR is the customer
preferred solution.
As an integrated truck and engine OEM,
our collaborative engineering teams will
deliver International customers the best total
ownership experience and cost structure for
your business. |
Here are the facts:
- EGR allows business as usual after
2010 for International truck owners with
MaxxForce engines.
- EGR is a simple and proven technology.
- EGR is simpler to maintain and operate.
- There are no radical hardware additions
with Advanced EGR.
No Urea tanks, no additional catalysts,
sensors, gauges or electronics with EGR
systems.
- No additional fl uids are required for vehicle
operation with EGR.
- There are no worries about availability of
Urea with EGR.
- Service technicians understand and know
how to service EGR based products.
- TEM’s do not have to re-engineer bodies and
functional components to accommodate
new hardware and packaging.
|
 |
The same confidence customers have in today’s products will carry forward in 2010 with
a proven EGR solution. This effective technology, that is well understood, is simple to
maintain and provides you peace of mind with “Advanced Simplicity”.
2010 looks like 2007 with Navistar’s “Advanced Simplicity” EGR technology. 2007 saw the
introduction of after-treatment into the market with EGR. The conventional wisdom was a
decrease in fuel economy. The facts are 2007 MaxxForce engines in International® trucks
showed fuel economy gains up to 7-12%.
The technologies used include:
- High pressure fuel injection with multiple injections per combustion event
- Cylinder bowl optimization
- Cooled Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) and
Diesel Particulate Filter (DPF) after treatment
to control Particulate Matter (soot) out of the
exhaust to virtually zero [0.01 g/hp-hr].
|
 |
SCR Offers More Complexity For Customers
European and some North American-based OEMs are taking the path of “more complexity”
with Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) after-treatment technology.
SCR is burdensome for customers...
- Emissions compliance is transferred to the customer who must maintain an adequate
supply of urea or face operating interruptions.
- SCR requires the use of Urea to be mixed into the exhaust stream and act as a reduction
agent to break down NOx into Nitrogen (N2) and water.
- SCR technology would add additional hardware to the existing 2007 particulate after
treatment hardware shown in the illustration below.
This solution adds cost, packaging challenges and complexity to achieve 2010 emissions
reduction with SCR.
But there are other issues that you need consider when using an SCR solution. |
 |
| Navistar has announced that it will be fully compliant in 2010 and its core
commercial truck applications will NOT use SCR.
This offers customers payload continuity, reduced complexity and service
continuity with no extra training and a clean air solution allowing business
as usual. |
More SCR Facts
- There is no delivery infrastructure in place
to support Urea distribution in North America
for 2010.
- The need for Urea demands a separate
tank on the truck that will add weight and
reduce payload.
– A line haul vehicle may require a 40 gallon
tank that would need fi lling every 12,000
– 24,000 miles based upon fuel use.
– The Urea tank must be well insulated to
prevent decomposing in hot climates and
heated to prevent
freezing in
cold climates.
- Urea is Temperature dependant.
– If Urea is exposed to >105°F the urea will
decompose rapidly.
– Urea will freeze at ~10°F. Urea must be
thawed very quickly with engine coolant
[about 30 min.] or with the use of electric
heaters [requiring power consumption
- A mixer and Urea doser [injector] are
required in addition to the SCR catalyst to
achieve the NOx reduction.
- Urea alarms or engine de-rating would be
required to assure the use of Urea to achieve
emissions goals.
- Urea use will add to diagnostic system
requirements.
- SCR Urea must be a high grade and a precise
solution to avoid catalyst damage and assure
system integrity.
- Urea has varied commercial and agricultural
uses: Fertilizers, barbiturate synthesis, urea
formaldehyde, plastics and polyurethanes. It
is important to select and use the
correct grade.
- Urea costs are driven by agricultural
demand, automotive purity requirements and
infrastructure and distributions equirements.
- Estimated SCR hardware costs are several
More SCR Facts
thousands of dollars per truck in addition to
the 2007 after-treatment costs we
have today.
|
 |